Boys Basketball: Coolman scores 26 in loss to No. 1 Fishers

Penn Sophmore Point Guard Caleb Coolman scored 26 points but the No. 12 Kingsmen were defeated by No. 1 (Class 4-A) Fishers 74-54 on Saturday, Feb. 14, 2026.

Coolman also had four assists for the Kingsmen (15-5).

Coolman surpassed Penn’s Sophomore scoring record on Friday, Feb. 13, scoring 21 points against South Bend Washington. A 6-foot-5 All-State candidate, Coolman now has 425 points this season, topping the previous Sophomore season best of 394 points set by Notre Dame star Markus Burton in the 2020-2021 season.

Lucas Obermeyer scored 14 points for the Kingsmen.

PENN 54: Mi’Kell Burton 6, Ben Murphy 2, Caleb Martinez 0, Caleb Coolman 26, Lucas Obermeyer 14, Cody Evans 0, Christian Bonner 4, Makale Price 2.

Fishers 74: Jean-Claude L’Homme 10, Cooper Zachary 13, Levi Walker 8, Tristan Breland 6, Torey Breland 0, Kai McGrew 18, Max Hopkins 2, Jalen Campbell 0, Ethan Hillsman 17, Dominic Mulenga 0, Micaiah Baker 0.

PENN          10     10     20     14 – 54

Fisher           17     16     20     21 – 74

Three-pointers: PENN 6 (Lucas Obermeyer 4, Caleb Coolman 2), Fishers 7 (L’Homme 2, Walker 2, Cooper Zachary 1, Tristan Breland 1, Hillsman 1).